treasure for your pleasure

a marie antoinette blog

140 notes

Ken Jennings on the “Let them eat cake! myth: (via Woot.com)
If you learned one thing about Marie Antoinette in school it was  probably this: she was an extravagant flake who partied while her people  starved, and she lost her head for it in 1793 when the Revolution came.  The “Let them eat cake” story is often used to prop up this image of  the Queen as frivolous and out of touch: when told that her people were  starving for want of bread, Marie is said to have nonchalantly replied, “Qu’ils mangent de la brioche”—in  other words, that the poor should just chill out and try some cake  (well, brioche, anyway, which is rich, eggy bread) instead. The story  was trotted out yet again last week to describe the financiers sipping  champagne and sneering at the “Occupy Wall Street” protestors in New  York City.
The first problem with the “Let them eat cake” story is that it’s chronologically impossible. It dates back to the Confessions of philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who attributes it to a “a great  princess.” But Rousseau wrote those words in 1765, when Marie Antoinette  was only nine years old. Unless Rousseau had a time machine, Marie  Antoinette couldn’t have been the princess he was thinking of.
The second problem with the story is that it’s unfair to Marie—who, many  historians now argue, wasn’t really a bad sort. Sure, she liked to  dance and gamble and dress up, especially when she was young, but soon  grew out of her “Girls Gone Wild” phase. For most of her life, she was a  modest teetotaler who tried to reform the licentious excesses of the  French court, and gave liberally to the poor. In 1770, she and the king  decided to give up a year of their income; it was donated to a fund for  the victims of a tragic stampede that had killed 800 Parisians at a  fireworks celebration earlier that year. She later adopted three poor  children that she raised herself, and cared for many other peasant  families. And in the famine of 1787, she sold the royal silver to buy  grain for her people, while serving her own family the same coarse  barley bread that the poor ate. No cake for her - not that it did her  any long-term good in the court of public opinion.

Ken Jennings on the “Let them eat cake! myth: (via Woot.com)

If you learned one thing about Marie Antoinette in school it was probably this: she was an extravagant flake who partied while her people starved, and she lost her head for it in 1793 when the Revolution came. The “Let them eat cake” story is often used to prop up this image of the Queen as frivolous and out of touch: when told that her people were starving for want of bread, Marie is said to have nonchalantly replied, “Qu’ils mangent de la brioche”—in other words, that the poor should just chill out and try some cake (well, brioche, anyway, which is rich, eggy bread) instead. The story was trotted out yet again last week to describe the financiers sipping champagne and sneering at the “Occupy Wall Street” protestors in New York City.

The first problem with the “Let them eat cake” story is that it’s chronologically impossible. It dates back to the Confessions of philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who attributes it to a “a great princess.” But Rousseau wrote those words in 1765, when Marie Antoinette was only nine years old. Unless Rousseau had a time machine, Marie Antoinette couldn’t have been the princess he was thinking of.

The second problem with the story is that it’s unfair to Marie—who, many historians now argue, wasn’t really a bad sort. Sure, she liked to dance and gamble and dress up, especially when she was young, but soon grew out of her “Girls Gone Wild” phase. For most of her life, she was a modest teetotaler who tried to reform the licentious excesses of the French court, and gave liberally to the poor. In 1770, she and the king decided to give up a year of their income; it was donated to a fund for the victims of a tragic stampede that had killed 800 Parisians at a fireworks celebration earlier that year. She later adopted three poor children that she raised herself, and cared for many other peasant families. And in the famine of 1787, she sold the royal silver to buy grain for her people, while serving her own family the same coarse barley bread that the poor ate. No cake for her - not that it did her any long-term good in the court of public opinion.

Filed under marie antoinette ken jennings jeopardy myths history

  1. gealach24 reblogged this from vivelareine and added:
    Med tanke på att jag hade anledning att prata om det här idag:
  2. johnzilla87 reblogged this from alltimebestfriend
  3. intothewildfire reblogged this from vivelareine and added:
    Marie Antoinette: The last Queen of France
  4. mrstickfigure reblogged this from drewmecloser
  5. aashgasm reblogged this from madelineinvines
  6. maststocedartrees reblogged this from longdeadstar and added:
    My European history professor from last year would add that the phrase was likely in reference to a law requiring...
  7. longdeadstar reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  8. stayceerantsandraves reblogged this from mygayshoes
  9. mygayshoes reblogged this from psychetimelapse
  10. mistakenforaman reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  11. lettherecordshow reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  12. imscotch01 reblogged this from visionsofpetrichor
  13. fredanel reblogged this from visionsofpetrichor
  14. visionsofpetrichor reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  15. kayeighty reblogged this from matafarty
  16. ajexification reblogged this from coffeeandicecream
  17. coffeeandicecream reblogged this from gracefullyvintage
  18. thesea--wolf reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  19. babeofbiscay reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  20. longroadstonowhere reblogged this from wellwhenigrew
  21. drowningaltair reblogged this from langerdibs
  22. pegamento reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  23. carmennn reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  24. drewmecloser reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  25. smutseat reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  26. madelineinvines reblogged this from lipsredasroses
  27. langerdibs reblogged this from trulysophisticat